Deep-Dish Pizza The famous one
Citywide · $$
Photo: Just Plane Silly
Why it made the list: The one everyone comes for, a buttery, high-walled crust filled with cheese, chunky tomato sauce on top, and enough heft to double as lunch and dinner. Locals eat it less often than tourists think, but it's a genuine Chicago invention and a rite of passage. There's also the thinner, cheesier 'stuffed' version to complicate the argument.
Italian Beef The local's pick
Citywide · $
Photo: R (Kleft)
Why it made the list: The sandwich Chicagoans actually love: thin-sliced roast beef piled on a roll, soaked in seasoned jus, topped with sweet peppers or spicy giardiniera. It's messy, cheap, and the real hometown hero, arguably more Chicago than the pizza.
The Chicago-Style Hot Dog
Citywide · $
Photo: Portillo's & Barnelli's Chicago
Why it made the list: A Vienna Beef dog on a poppy-seed bun, 'dragged through the garden': yellow mustard, chopped onion, neon-green relish, a dill pickle spear, tomato slices, sport peppers, and a dash of celery salt. One thing it never has is ketchup, a rule locals take only half-jokingly seriously.
The Jibarito Invented here
Humboldt Park · $
Photo: Uly Cruz
Why it made the list: Chicago's own Puerto Rican invention, a sandwich that swaps the bread for two flattened, fried green plantains, layered with steak, cheese, lettuce, tomato and garlicky mayo. Created in the city's Puerto Rican community, it's the most underrated iconic eat here and a reason to go to Humboldt Park.
The Maxwell Street Polish Late night
Citywide · $
Photo: Thorsten Zeizinger
Why it made the list: A grilled Polish sausage on a bun, buried under caramelized grilled onions, mustard and sport peppers, born on the old Maxwell Street Market and now the city's classic late-night, working-Chicago food. Cheap, smoky, and exactly right at 1am.
⭐ Bonus Pick: Garrett Popcorn (The 'Chicago Mix')
The edible souvenir: Garrett's caramel-and-cheese popcorn mix, locals call it the 'Chicago Mix', sold in tins along Michigan Avenue. It sounds strange, the line is often out the door, and it is completely worth it. Get a bag of the mixed and eat it walking down the Mag Mile.
This page contains affiliate links, including Expedia. If you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend places we'd actually go.
